Uncovering the Mystery of Bernice Williams’ Headstone in Nashville

News Summary

The headstone of Bernice Williams, crafted by local artist William Edmondson, holds a rich history filled with mystery and intrigue. Though created in 1933, it remained unclaimed by her family, prompting questions about its past and the story it tells of love, loss, and community connections in Nashville. With an enigmatic inscription and a complex narrative concerning identity, this headstone serves as a poignant reminder of the intertwined lives that have shaped the fabric of local history.

Uncovering the Mystery of Bernice Williams’ Headstone in Nashville

Nashville has always had its fair share of captivating stories, but few are as intriguing as the tale of Bernice Williams’ headstone, an elegant piece carved by the talented local artist William Edmondson. This remarkable artifact is not only part of the Tennessee State Museum’s collection but holds secrets of love, loss, and perhaps even buried friendships that refuse to fade from memory.

A Headstone Left Behind

At first glance, the gravestone might look like any other, but what it represents is layered with mystery and unanswered questions. Carved by Edmondson—a prominent figure in Nashville’s art scene—the headstone features a charming lamb motif, a signature style of the artist. Interestingly, this headstone was crafted for Bernice Williams in 1933, but, rather curiously, it was never claimed by her family. Instead, it sat untouched, tucked away in Edmondson’s own yard until his death in 1951.

The Price of Time

In 1937, this beautiful headstone was valued at around $40, a significant amount for that era. However, the true value may lie in its condition today, which remains excellent, thanks in part to its abandonment. Jim Hoobler, the museum’s senior curator, notes that the lack of familial ownership has resulted in less wear and tear, allowing the headstone to thrive through the years.

The Enigmatic Inscription

Upon closer inspection, one can see that while the birth date inscribed on the stone is 1906, only three digits are fully visible; the kerning of the numbers means that the final ‘6’ can barely be seen on the side of the stone. What could this tell us about its past? It raises even more questions about the woman it represents and the man who commissioned this intricate carving.

The Man Behind the Stone

Robert Williams, who is said to have commissioned the headstone for his wife, never claimed it. A search into Nashville’s historical records reveals that, in 1930, there were five Black men named Robert Williams, yet none appeared to have a wife named Bernice. This fact alone adds layers of confusion to the narrative surrounding this headstone.

The True Identity

As detective work often goes, a new lead emerged. Investigators explored the possibility that the real Bernice Williams might actually be a woman named Birdie Compton. She tragically died from tuberculosis on January 9, 1931. Born Bernice Batey, Birdie’s age and death date align with the inscription. However, there’s still a twist; she had no known ties to a Robert Williams. How could the name have changed over time, or perhaps been recorded incorrectly?

The Legacy of Love and Loss

There’s a historical backdrop to this narrative involving a plantation in the Compton family, hinting at the complex legacy of class and race. It begs the question: did William Edmondson have a connection to Birdie’s story or the local community? Was this headstone more than a job for him? Evidence suggests he often made headstones for people he personally knew, further deepening the enigma around this piece.

A Community’s History

The ultimate reason for the mistaken last name of “Williams” remains unclear, but it highlights a fascinating aspect of existence in Nashville’s past. This headstone represents not just one individual, but could be connected to a broader theme of community and memory that runs deep through local Black history.

The story of Bernice or Birdie Williams and her headstone is one of lingering questions and unresolved histories. It encourages us all to reflect on how we remember our past and the stories carried through generations. So, as Nashville continues to evolve, the legacy etched in this stone serves as a poignant reminder of the lives that helped shape it.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

HERE Resources

Additional Resources

• Nashville Scene: William Edmondson & Bernice Williams
• Wikipedia: William Edmondson
• Art and Object: William Edmondson’s Sculpture
• Google Search: William Edmondson
• The New York Times: Southern Art
• Encyclopedia Britannica: William Edmondson