North Nashville’s Iconic Mary’s Old Fashioned Pit Bar-B-Que Restaurant Listed for Sale

North Nashville’s Beloved BBQ Spot Hits the Market

Hey, folks! Big news coming out of North Nashville this week that’s bound to tug at your heartstrings if you’re a fan of old-school barbecue. The iconic restaurant, Mary’s Old Fashioned Pit Bar-B-Que, has officially been listed for sale, and we can’t help but reflect on what this gem has meant to its community over the decades.

A Slice of History

Located at 1108 Jefferson St. in the charming Buena Vista neighborhood, this notable pit stop opened its doors in 1967. That’s right, folks—it’s been serving delicious barbecue for over half a century! The building itself boasts a sprawling 10,489-square-foot space nestled on a generous 0.54 acres of land. And here’s a fun fact: the property isn’t just home to the restaurant; it also houses a Boost Mobile store, giving it that perfect blend of nostalgia and modern convenience.

Family Legacy

The ownership of the property has remained in the family for quite some time. According to Metro records, family ties trace back to as early as 1972. Co-founder Mary “Mama Mary” Seals joined forces with Willis Childress to kick off this beloved establishment in 1962. What’s even more heartwarming is that the restaurant is now run by Katresa Fizer, who proudly carries on her grandmother’s legacy.

A Taste of Tradition

Let’s talk about the food for a moment. If you’ve ever set foot in Mary’s, you know what a feast it is! The smoke-infused flavors, the perfectly cooked meats, and those iconic sides are hard to beat. From juicy ribs to pulled pork that melts in your mouth, it’s a culinary experience you just can’t find anywhere else. This restaurant has become more than just a place to grab a bite—it’s a cultural touchstone for the North Nashville community.

The Aftermath of Sale

The building is being marketed by local experts Rob Lowe and Troynell Reese from the Nashville-based Stream Realty. While the asking price remains undisclosed, the potential for new ownership opens the door to a lot of possibilities. Will the new owners maintain the restaurant’s rich history and cherished menu? Or will they pivot to a completely different business? This is a burning question on many locals’ minds as they reminisce about their favorite meals at Mary’s.

Community Memories

Many locals are sharing their fond memories of dining at Mary’s, celebrating life milestones, and bonding with family and friends over heaping plates of food. Regular visitors recall the warm smiles from the staff and the unparalleled sense of community that the restaurant fostered. As the listing appears, it’s essential for everyone to reflect on what this establishment has meant—and still means—to many.

What’s Next?

As buyers begin to consider this unique opportunity, all eyes will be on the future. Will this beloved spot get a new lease on life, or will its legacy become just another chapter in North Nashville’s story? This could be a chance for someone to bring fresh ideas while respecting the rich traditions that have made Mary’s an enduring favorite.

For now, as potential buyers assess the building’s value and community members reminisce about their memories, one thing is for sure: Mary’s Old Fashioned Pit Bar-B-Que will always hold a treasured place in the hearts of many, and it will be exciting to see where this story goes from here.